lichess.org
Donate

Three Move Repetition Not Detected

I entered the same position three times, with the same player to move. However, I was unable to claim a draw.

The position after white's 29th, 31st, and 33rd moves are identical, so a draw should be claimable. Here's the game: http://en.lichess.org/UXgpUTTl

Here's a video stream of the game, and you can see that I was never able to claim the draw, even on the opponent's turn. You can skip to the 5 minute mark, where this occurs. http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/46503608

I should be able to click "claim a draw" after 32. ...Kf7, accord to the FIDE Rules of Chess, because of my ability to play 33. Qd5+ and repeat the position. I should not have to actually play Qd5+, which is important, because then I would not have time to click "claim a draw" before the opponent responded with Ke8.

Here is the rule from the FIDE laws of chess, section 9.2. I should be able to claim a draw under scenario A. http://www.fide.com/fide/handbook.html?id=124&view=article

The game is drawn, upon a correct claim by the player having the move, when the same position, for at least the third time (not necessarily by sequential repetition of moves)

a. is about to appear, if he first writes his move on his scoresheet and declares to the arbiter his intention to make this move, or
b. has just appeared, and the player claiming the draw has the move.
I'm not a hundred percents sure, but I think lichess gets it right.

"The game is drawn upon a correct claim by the player having the move, when the same position, for at least the third time".

The only time when a position was repeated three times was after 33. Qd5+ lichess.org/UXgpUTTl#65

At this moment, your opponent has the move. According to FIDE rules, he gets the chance to draw. He did see the link appear, but he did not click it; instead he went Ke8, breaking the repetition.

There has never be a threefold repetition when it was your turn to play.
So you did not get the chance to draw and I think it is normal.

Or did I miss something?
Lichess doesn't have it right, but it's tricky. You have to read further, into the two scenarios, which give white a chance to claim a draw. FIDE says:

"The game is drawn, upon a correct claim by the player having the move, when the same position, for at least the third time (not necessarily by sequential repetition of moves)

a. is about to appear, if he first writes his move on his scoresheet and declares to the arbiter his intention to make this move, or
b. has just appeared, and the player claiming the draw has the move."

The reason both (a) and (b) appear here is to allow both sides in positions like this to claim a draw. If this were a FIDE game, I would be able to claim via "Scenario A" just before 33. Qd5+, by "declaring to the arbiter my intention to make this move." The right way to fix this in online games is to give white the option to claim instead of (and before) playing 33. Qd5+. During the game, I was watching for this option, but it didn't appear.

An alternative is to give the draw option to white after Ke8, since that's the first time it's white's move after the repetition has appeared, but that would not match the FIDE rules.
also to note:

the end game draws change from before (?)
the ratings are not FIDE
this is online chess not FIDE

i would make it automatic.
Yeah, of course the most salient point is that this is not FIDE rated, and thus not all rules must follow FIDE to the letter (shall we also apply touch move, for example?)

Having said that, I do think the handling of three move repetition draws should be improved. I've actually never had to claim a threefold repetition draw here, so I tested it by playing a game against myself.

It turns out that if you make the move that brings about the third repetition of the position, you cannot make the claim at all here. Only the player who is to move AFTER the third repetition of the position has the option to claim the draw, which is a bit odd.

The handling should be changed so that both players are able to make the claim, possibly with the player who brought about the third repetition of the position being able to make the claim after his opponent's reply as well (to avoid his opponent being able to make some random move to prevent the claim).
Maybe there could be a 'Claim threefold repetition draw?' popup after the player has made its move and before the oponent could make its move. Like the pawn promotion.
I think I like Legend's suggestion best. Simply have the draw be automatic (in the example in the opening post, this would be after 33. Qd5+). It could happen in the same way that the 50-move rule currently does.

Anyway, I think something should be done, because I wanted a draw for that game! :-)
I think I suggested this a while ago; to have an account setting where you can 'Claim threefold draw automatically'. It's just too tedious to try and press the button while in bullet games, or blitz end-games when time and concentration is pressing.
#4
^ This

Theres autopromote to queen (if im not mistaken) and premove. I cant see why the draw when repetition shouldnt be automatic.

This topic has been archived and can no longer be replied to.